12th Fail (2023) is a biographical drama directed by Vidhu Vinod Chopra, based on the real-life story of IPS officer Manoj Kumar Sharma. The film follows Manoj, a young man from a poor village in Chambal, where cheating in exams is common. After failing his 12th-grade exams due to a crackdown on cheating, Manoj is inspired by an honest police officer to pursue a career in the Indian Police Service. Image source: IMDB
Read these first:
- Hindi Movie Review: URI Surgical Strike 2019, Intense and Surgical
- Hindi Movie Review: Eye-Opening, Shocking Article 15 Thriller 2019
- Hindi Movie Review: Rocket Singh: Salesman of the Year 2009
- Indian Cinema 101: Hindi Movies, Now & Then
- Civil Service 2020: Anil Swarup’s Making Things Happen in the Government
Introduction to ’12th Fail’
12th Fail (2023) is a biographical drama directed by Vidhu Vinod Chopra, based on Anurag Pathak’s novel Twelfth Fail. The film chronicles the inspiring journey of IPS officer Manoj Kumar Sharma, portrayed by Vikrant Massey, from a poverty-stricken village background to overcoming academic setbacks and succeeding in the highly competitive UPSC examination. Co-starring Medha Shankr as IRS officer Shraddha Joshi, the film emphasizes themes of perseverance, resilience, and determination. It was released theatrically on October 27, 2023, and became a sleeper hit, grossing over ₹69 crore (US$8.2 million) worldwide on a ₹20 crore (US$2.4 million) budget.
Real-life UPSC aspirants were cast for authenticity, and both Sharma and Joshi made cameo appearances. UPSC coach Vikas Divyakirti played himself. 12th Fail received widespread critical acclaim for its compelling narrative and stellar performances, particularly Massey’s. It won five awards at the 69th Filmfare Awards 2024, including Best Film, Best Director (Vidhu Vinod Chopra), and Best Actor (Critics) for Vikrant Massey. At the Critics’ Choice Awards 2024, it secured the Best Feature Film Award, with Massey earning Best Actor. The film was nominated for Best Film and Critics’ Best Film at the Filmfare Awards 2024, reflecting its industry impact.
Plot Overview
12th Fail (2023) is a biographical drama that follows the life of Manoj Kumar Sharma, a determined young man from a poverty-stricken village in Chambal, India, as he strives to become an IPS officer. The story begins with Manoj (Vikrant Massey) facing academic challenges, failing his 12th-grade exams due to systemic issues and his family’s financial struggles. Despite societal stigma and personal setbacks, Manoj refuses to give up, drawing inspiration from his father’s integrity and his ambition to serve the nation.
Leaving his village, Manoj arrives in Delhi to prepare for the UPSC examination, one of India’s toughest competitive exams. He immerses himself in the grueling world of UPSC coaching hubs, facing financial hardship, self-doubt, and intense competition. Along the way, he meets Shraddha Joshi (Medha Shankr), a fellow aspirant who becomes his emotional anchor and eventual life partner. Manoj’s journey is marked by repeated failures, including multiple unsuccessful attempts at the UPSC prelims and mains, but his resilience keeps him pushing forward. With guidance from mentors and unwavering determination, he refines his skills and mindset.
The film builds to a gripping climax as Manoj faces the final UPSC interview, where his honesty and conviction shine through. Ultimately, he achieves his dream, becoming an IPS officer, while Shraddha becomes an IRS officer. 12th Fail is a heartfelt tale of perseverance, showcasing Manoj’s transformation from a “12th fail” student to a symbol of hope, proving that failure is merely a stepping stone to success.
Please accept YouTube cookies to play this video. By accepting you will be accessing content from YouTube, a service provided by an external third party.
If you accept this notice, your choice will be saved and the page will refresh.
.
The trailer for the movie 12th Fail showcases the inspiring true story of Manoj Kumar Sharma, who overcame immense challenges to rise from humble beginnings to become the Inspector General of Police in the Central Industrial Security Force. Directed by Vidhu Vinod Chopra, the film highlights Sharma’s relentless determination, struggles with academic setbacks, and unwavering pursuit of his dream to serve as an IPS officer.
Union Public Service Commission (UPSC)
UPSC Background
The Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) is India’s premier central recruiting agency, responsible for conducting examinations for All India Services and Group A and B posts under the Union Government. Its origins trace back to the colonial era, evolving through several key milestones:
After India gained independence in 1947, the Federal Public Service Commission was reconstituted as the Union Public Service Commission on October 26, 1950, under Article 315 of the Indian Constitution. The UPSC was tasked with ensuring a meritocratic selection process for the country’s administrative framework, including services like the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), Indian Police Service (IPS), and Indian Foreign Service (IFS).
UPSC Exam Format
The UPSC Civil Services Examination is a highly competitive, three-stage process to recruit candidates for prestigious services like IAS, IPS, IFS, and other Group A and B posts. Conducted annually, it tests candidates’ knowledge, aptitude, and personality.
1. Preliminary Examination (Prelims)
The UPSC Civil Services Preliminary Examination (Prelims) serves as a screening stage to shortlist candidates for the Main Examination. It consists of two objective-type papers conducted on the same day. General Studies Paper-I (GS-I) covers topics such as Indian history, geography, polity, economy, environment, science, and current affairs, carrying 200 marks with 100 questions (2 marks each, 1/3 negative marking) and a duration of 2 hours.
General Studies Paper-II (CSAT), which tests reading comprehension, logical reasoning, and quantitative aptitude, also carries 200 marks with 80 questions (2.5 marks each, 1/3 negative marking) and lasts 2 hours; it is qualifying in nature, requiring a minimum of 33% to pass. Only GS-I marks determine qualification for the Mains, with an annual cut-off typically ranging between 90 and 110. Both papers are offered in English and Hindi.
2. Main Examination (Mains)
The UPSC Main Examination is a rigorous written exam designed to test candidates’ in-depth knowledge and analytical skills, conducted over 5–7 days. It comprises nine descriptive papers, divided into qualifying and merit-based components. The qualifying papers include Paper A (an Indian language chosen from the Eighth Schedule, 300 marks) and Paper B (English, 300 marks), both requiring a minimum of 25% to pass but not contributing to the final ranking.
The seven merit-based papers, totaling 1750 marks, include an Essay paper (250 marks) requiring two essays, General Studies I (250 marks) covering heritage, culture, history, and geography, General Studies II (250 marks) focusing on governance, polity, and international relations, General Studies III (250 marks) addressing technology, economy, environment, and security, General Studies IV (250 marks) on ethics, integrity, and aptitude, and two papers (250 marks each) on an optional subject chosen by the candidate, such as Public Administration or Sociology.
The Mains is highly competitive, with the optional subject choice being critical to success, and only candidates who qualify in the language papers have their merit-based papers evaluated.
3. Personality Test (Interview)
The Personality Test, or Interview, of the UPSC Civil Services Examination evaluates a candidate’s personality, leadership qualities, and suitability for a career in civil services. Conducted by a UPSC board in New Delhi, this conversational stage carries 275 marks and typically lasts 20–30 minutes. It focuses on assessing mental alertness, critical thinking, ethical judgment, and awareness of current issues. The interview tests the candidate’s confidence and communication skills, playing a crucial role in determining their final ranking.
Final Merit
The final merit of the UPSC Civil Services Examination is determined by combining the scores from the Main Examination, which carries 1750 marks, and the Personality Test (Interview), which contributes 275 marks, resulting in a total of 2025 marks. Candidates who achieve top ranks are allocated prestigious services such as the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), Indian Police Service (IPS), or Indian Foreign Service (IFS), depending on their preferences, available vacancies, and overall merit.
Additional Notes
The Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) Civil Services Examination is open to graduates of any discipline, aged 21–32, with age relaxations for reserved categories. Candidates are limited to six attempts (more for reserved categories). Conducted annually, the Prelims typically occur in May or June, followed by the Mains in September or October.
The exam is notoriously challenging, with a vast syllabus, a low success rate of approximately 0.2% of applicants succeeding, and a preparation period often spanning 1–2 years, as vividly portrayed in the film *12th Fail*. Recent posts on X reflect ongoing discussions about the exam’s difficulty, with aspirants exchanging strategies and motivational stories, underscoring its reputation for fairness and its critical role in shaping India’s bureaucracy.
Please accept YouTube cookies to play this video. By accepting you will be accessing content from YouTube, a service provided by an external third party.
If you accept this notice, your choice will be saved and the page will refresh.
.
The UPSC Civil Services Interview, also known as the Personality Test, is the final stage of the Civil Services Examination, carrying 275 marks. Its primary objective is to assess a candidate’s suitability for a career in civil services, focusing on personality traits rather than just knowledge, which is already tested in the Prelims and Mains. The interview typically lasts 20–30 minutes and involves a panel of 4–5 members, chaired by a UPSC board member. It is designed to be a two-way conversation, testing not just knowledge but how candidates present themselves under scrutiny.
Character Analysis
The 2023 Indian Hindi-language biographical drama 12th Fail, directed by Vidhu Vinod Chopra, is based on Anurag Pathak’s novel about the real-life journey of IPS officer Manoj Kumar Sharma. The film’s characters are richly crafted, blending authenticity with emotional depth to depict resilience, ambition, and human connection. Below is an analysis of the key characters, their roles, and their contributions to the narrative, drawing on the provided web sources and critical insights.
Manoj Kumar Sharma (Played by Vikrant Massey)
Manoj, the protagonist of the film, is a young man from the dacoit-infested village of Chambal, born into poverty with an honest but suspended father. Despite failing his 12th-grade exams, he aspires to become an Indian Police Service (IPS) officer by clearing the rigorous UPSC exam. His journey embodies a classic “rags to riches” narrative, driven by relentless perseverance and symbolized by his motto of “restart.” Manoj’s ambition is sparked by an honest police officer, DSP Dushyant Singh, who stops exam cheating, inspiring him to emulate such integrity.
Facing systemic challenges—financial struggles, academic setbacks, and societal pressures—Manoj takes on odd jobs as a tempo driver, dog walker, and mill worker to fund his UPSC preparation. His emotional authenticity and refusal to compromise on honesty make him a relatable everyman, with Vikrant Massey’s “unalloyed brilliance” earning widespread praise for portraying Manoj’s sincerity and grit. Manoj’s dynamic arc, from a naive village boy to a determined IPS officer, resonates with audiences, representing the indomitable spirit of millions of UPSC aspirants and reflecting universal themes of resilience and purpose.
Critics note Massey’s ability to make Manoj feel “real and grounded,” blurring the line between fiction and reality. However, some argue the film overly romanticizes struggle, with Manoj’s constant grin and the narrative’s focus on “repeat, repeat” lacking deeper exploration of the psychological toll.
Shraddha Joshi (Played by Medha Shankr)
Shraddha, Manoj’s love interest and eventual wife, is an IRS officer and UPSC aspirant whose poised, fair-skinned, and classy demeanor contrasts sharply with Manoj’s rustic background. Introduced in Delhi, her relationship with Manoj evolves from a tentative situationship into a profound emotional anchor, marked by pivotal moments such as their reconciliation after a fallout over Manoj’s academic honesty in Mussoorie. Despite her elegance and unwavering support, Shraddha’s character remains static, primarily serving as a motivator for Manoj’s journey.
Critics, particularly from a feminist perspective, argue she embodies the “Manic Pixie Dream Girl” trope, existing to inspire Manoj without a fully developed arc of her own. While her IRS success is acknowledged, it is only briefly mentioned, leaving her ambitions underexplored and her narrative secondary, rendering her a “coat hanger” for Manoj’s story.
Nevertheless, Shraddha’s relationship with Manoj adds emotional depth, grounding his struggles in human connection, with her apology and confession of love post-Mussoorie highlighting her role as a stabilizing force. This underdevelopment represents a missed opportunity for a more balanced portrayal of a real-life IRS officer.
Pritam Pandey (Played by Anant V Joshi)
Pritam, Manoj’s friend and the film’s narrator, is a UPSC aspirant who provides both commentary and emotional support throughout the story. His third-person omniscient narration frames Manoj’s journey, offering an outsider’s perspective on the challenges faced in Delhi’s competitive coaching hubs.
As a friend, Pritam plays a vital role, offering companionship and encouragement, with Anant Joshi’s “superb” narration enhancing the film’s emotional resonance and making Pritam a relatable guide for the audience. His character adds a layer of camaraderie, reflecting the collective struggle of UPSC aspirants, while his narration bridges the audience with Manoj’s internal and external battles, amplifying the film’s inspirational tone. However, as a static character, Pritam lacks personal depth, serving primarily to advance Manoj’s story, which limits the complexity of his role.
Gauri Bhaiya (Played by Anshumaan Pushkar)
Gauri serves as a mentor and friend to Manoj, offering him a place to live and encouraging him to abandon odd jobs to focus on his studies. As one of the sympathetic figures in the film, Gauri embodies the theme of kindness from strangers, acting as a catalyst in Manoj’s success by urging him to prioritize his UPSC preparation.
His decision to move Manoj into his own house underscores his pivotal role in Manoj’s journey. Gauri represents the unsung heroes whose small acts of support can profoundly change lives, with Anshumaan Pushkar’s grounded portrayal adding authenticity to the film’s depiction of community. However, like Shraddha and Pritam, Gauri’s character remains static, existing primarily to bolster Manoj’s arc without significant personal development.
DSP Dushyant Singh (Played by Priyanshu Chatterjee)
Dushyant, a strict and honest police officer, serves as a pivotal figure in shaping Manoj’s dream of becoming an IPS officer. His decisive intervention during Manoj’s 12th-grade exams, where he stops cheating, results in Manoj’s failure but plants the seed of ambition to emulate Dushyant’s integrity.
Though his role is brief, Dushyant’s moral exemplar status profoundly influences Manoj’s worldview, further reinforced when he aids Manoj and his brother against local goons. As a symbol of the honesty Manoj aspires to, Dushyant acts as the catalyst for his journey, embodying the film’s message that meritocratic success remains possible in India despite systemic corruption. However, his limited screen time renders him more of a plot device than a fully developed character, though his impact on the narrative is undeniable.
The characters in 12th Fail are crafted with a balance of realism and emotional resonance, driving the film’s narrative of hope and perseverance. Manoj Kumar Sharma stands out as a compelling protagonist, with Vikrant Massey’s performance anchoring the story. Supporting characters like Shraddha, Pritam, and Gauri enrich the narrative, though some lack depth due to the film’s focus on Manoj. The inclusion of real-life figures and aspirants enhances authenticity, making 12th Fail a poignant reflection of human struggle and triumph, despite critiques of idealization and underdeveloped subplots.
Please accept YouTube cookies to play this video. By accepting you will be accessing content from YouTube, a service provided by an external third party.
If you accept this notice, your choice will be saved and the page will refresh.
.
The ending scene of 12th Fail (2023), set a year after Manoj’s success in the UPSC Civil Services Examination, captures a moment of gratitude and closure, making it one of the film’s most impactful sequences. In the final moments, Manoj Kumar Sharma (played by Vikrant Massey), now an IPS officer, visits DSP Dushyant Singh, the officer who inspired him early in his journey. The interaction is brief but laden with emotion, as Manoj expresses his gratitude for Singh’s influence, and Singh acknowledges Manoj’s hard-earned success.
Lessons Learned from ’12th Fail’
’12th Fail’ encapsulates profound lessons that resonate deeply with students, particularly those embarking on challenging academic journeys. One of the central themes of the film is the notion of resilience. It encourages viewers to perceive failure not as a dead end but as a stepping stone towards success. The protagonist’s struggles serve as a mirror reflecting the reality that setbacks are often part of the path to achievement. This narrative is critical in helping students cultivate a positive mindset towards their failures, illustrating that these experiences can foster growth and development.
Additionally, ’12th Fail’ emphasizes the value of determination and hard work. The film portrays characters who, despite facing numerous obstacles, remain undeterred in their pursuit of goals. This unwavering commitment acts as a motivational force for students, inspiring them to work diligently towards their aspirations. The depiction of relentless effort reinforces the idea that success is rarely an instantaneous occurrence; rather, it is accumulated through consistent endeavors and perseverance.
Another significant takeaway from the film is the importance of a supportive community. The relationships depicted among the characters highlight how encouragement from peers, mentors, and family can play a crucial role in overcoming difficulties. It stresses that no one embarks on their journey alone; finding solidarity amidst adversity can create a robust support system that empowers individuals to confront their challenges head-on.
In essence, ’12th Fail’ serves as a powerful reminder that the journey towards success is fraught with hurdles. By embracing failure, maintaining resilience, committing to hard work, and leaning on support networks, students can navigate the complexities of their academic paths with a renewed sense of hope and determination. These lessons extend beyond the cinematic experience, resonating with anyone striving to carve their niche in a competitive landscape.
Please accept YouTube cookies to play this video. By accepting you will be accessing content from YouTube, a service provided by an external third party.
If you accept this notice, your choice will be saved and the page will refresh.
.
The film accurately captures the multifaceted nature of the UPSC interview, which assesses mental alertness, critical thinking, communication skills, and emotional intelligence. Questions posed to Manoj reflect real-life interview themes, such as situational dilemmas, current affairs, and personal background, aligning with the panel’s goal of evaluating a candidate’s suitability for civil services. The panel’s demeanor—professional yet intimidating—mirrors the real-life experience of facing UPSC board members, who often challenge candidates to reveal their true character under pressure.
Final Say
In contemplating the film ’12th Fail,’ it becomes evident that the narrative resonates deeply with the trials and tribulations faced by aspiring Indian Administrative Service (IAS) candidates. The storyline reflects the harsh realities of failure and the determination required to conquer the highly competitive landscape of civil services. Throughout its depiction, ’12th Fail’ accentuates the significance of resilience, highlighting how setbacks are intrinsic to the journey toward success. This portrayal not only encourages IAS aspirants to view failure as a stepping stone but also reinforces the idea that perseverance can yield fruitful results.
Moreover, the film serves as a critical commentary on the educational system and societal expectations. It challenges the conventional definitions of achievement, often linked strictly to academic performance, and promotes a broader understanding of success. By showcasing authentic experiences of the characters, it brings to light the pressures students experience, which can sometimes lead to mental health challenges. This aspect of the movie encourages important discussions about how society perceives failure and success, underscoring the need for a more compassionate view towards aspiring students.
Furthermore, ’12th Fail’ is not just a story of one individual; it encapsulates the collective experiences of numerous candidates who aspire to reach their goals amidst adversity. Its resonance extends beyond the confines of cinema, prompting viewers to reflect on their educational journeys and the societal structures that influence personal goals. The film’s broader impact lies in its ability to inspire change, advocating for a more supportive environment for students across the academic spectrum.
In summary, ’12th Fail’ stands out as an insightful portrayal of the IAS journey, amplifying the voices of aspirants while sparking meaningful dialogues about the nature of success in today’s competitive world.